Pick your scoop
Choose the surprise that feels right for you.
Discover a surprise selection of jewelry, chosen for the pleasure of finding something unexpected.
Choose your scoop →Call to order: 605-631-0992
Choose the surprise that feels right for you.
The best part is seeing what your scoop holds.
Discover the pieces that make you smile.
$30
$50
A little extra mysteryEvery order earns you one giveaway entry. After every 5 orders, a name is drawn to win a free mystery gift.
Choose a payment option below. Venmo appears when available.
Choose a payment option below. Venmo appears when available.
Includes 8 mystery jewelry pieces, 2 beauty goodies, 2 hair accessories, 1 stationery item, and 2 mystery gifts. Free shipping.
Choose a payment option below. Venmo appears when available.
Includes 2 mystery jewelry items, 1 cute accessory, and 1 diamond art painting kit. Free shipping.
Choose a payment option below. Venmo appears when available.
Free shipping on every scoop. Call 605-631-0992 for ordering help.
Find a charm in your bag? You get an extra gift!
Message to order →Looking for a mystery jewelry box with a colorful twist? Explore our Mini and Regular scoops.
A few of the styles you could discover. Photos show examples, each scoop is a surprise and pieces vary.



Athena’s mystery shop is based in Belle Fourche, South Dakota.